What Culture Actually Is. Monday’s Edition
All People Are the Same: They Just Do Things Differently. Series 22 #1
All people are the same: they just do things differently. This is my best simple way to explain culture.
Every person on earth wants safety, belonging, status, meaning, a sense of order, and the freedom to enjoy life. Nobody opts out of those needs. What varies, dramatically and systematically, is how different groups of people pursue them. That difference is culture.
Strip away language, religion, customs, and other cultural elements, and the underlying human wiring is consistent. Add them back in, and behavior diverges in ways that can look irrational to an outsider.
Geert Hofstede, the Dutch social psychologist, spent the better part of four decades mapping those cultural differences. Starting in the late 1960s, Hofstede analyzed survey data from IBM employees across more than 50 countries, people doing comparable jobs, in comparable organizations, under comparable conditions. What he found was that national culture produced consistent, measurable differences in how people thought about authority, individual identity, risk, success, time, and the freedom to enjoy life. He wasn’t measuring personality as Hornby did; he was measuring values, and values, unlike personality, are collective. A culture teaches its members what to want, what to fear, who to obey, what counts as success, how to relate to time, and how freely to enjoy life. and it does this so thoroughly that most people don’t notice that these are not choices, they are cultural programming
Hofstede identified six cultural dimensions. This week focuses on the four with the clearest behavioral evidence and the widest divergence between societies. Each one describes a specific cultural perspective that explains why people “do things differently.”
This week we will cover:
Individualism versus Collectivism, the degree to which people define themselves as independent agents or as members of a group.
Power Distance, the degree to which people accept and expect unequal distribution of power.
Uncertainty Avoidance, the degree to which people find ambiguity threatening rather than manageable.
Motivation towards Achievement and Success, the degree to which a culture points people toward competitive material success versus quality of life and relationships.
Each dimension produces behavior that makes complete sense within the cultural system that generates it, and can look baffling from the outside. A manager who never questions her supervisor isn’t weak; she’s operating inside a high power distance framework. An employee who turns down a promotion isn’t unambitious; he’s living out a quality-of-life value system. Misreading behavior because the underlying cultural system is invisible produces bad decisions in business, diplomacy, education, policy, any interaction with someone with a different cultural perspective.
Hofstede’s framework isn’t describing stereotypes. It describes distributions. No country is purely collectivist or purely individualist. Every society contains the full range of human variation. What the dimensions describe is the central tendency, the values a culture reinforces most consistently, the behaviors it rewards and punishes most often. That central tendency shapes institutions, laws, family structures, and management practices in ways that persist across generations.
Tuesday’s Edition opens with the dimension most readers will recognize in their own lives before they know its name: the difference between a culture built around “I” and one built around “we,” and how that difference affects everything from hiring decisions to family loyalty to public disagreement.
All of us humans are just doing things differently.
Sidebar
Hofstede’s original dataset covered more than 116,000 surveys collected between 1967 and 1973
Hofstede’s scores have been replicated and extended by independent researchers across subsequent decades, with national rankings remaining largely stable
The framework has been applied in fields ranging from international business and public health to conflict resolution and software design
geerthofstede.com provides self-assessment tools for readers who want to locate their own cultural profile across the dimensions
If you enjoyed this article, help support my work by becoming a paid subscriber or “buy me a coffee.”