Fentanyl. Taxes on American technology companies. Aircraft certification. Bridge tolls. Dairy. Provincial liquor sales. A television commercial featuring Ronald Reagan. Canadian wildfire smoke.
Mark Carney read that list out loud on 22 August 2026. Every item on it is a reason the Trump administration has given, at one point or another, for taxing Canadian goods. Smoke from a forest fire?
This is not trade policy. This is an unstable American president with no idea what he is doing.
On 20 July 2026, Trump signed three presidential orders that put a tariff in force without a vote in Congress. Together they put a 50 percent tax on 554 categories of Canadian goods, worth about $20 billion a year. They took effect on 22 August. Each one names its reason for the tariff. But all three reasons are domestic Canadian issues, which are not the concern of the U.S. government and are under the control of the provincial governments, not Ottawa.
Canadian provinces stopped selling American liquor. Sales fell 81 percent. Trump responded with a 50 percent tax on 63 categories of Canadian goods. But provinces regulate liquor stores in Canada. The prime minister does not have the power to dictate that a particular brand of liquor be put back on a shelf in Winnipeg. Trump’s own trade representative, Jamieson Greer, told Fox News this was the central sticking point in the negotiation. The Trump administration has no idea what it is doing.
Canadian cheese quotas. Canada lets European cheese makers ship more cheese into the country at a low tariff than it lets American ones. A European agreement and an American agreement signed years apart. Trump negotiated the American agreement and called it the best trade deal ever made.
Canada’s 25 percent surtax on American vehicles. Canada imposed it in 2025 in response to Trump’s tariffs on Canadian cars. US motor vehicle exports to Canada fell 22%, or $5.6 billion. Trump is upset that Canada is imposing a tariff because Trump imposed a tariff. Before Trump, there were no vehicle tariffs.
The Center for Strategic and International Studies checked the list attached to the vehicle order, and it says, “does not in fact include automobiles or auto parts at all—with the exception of motorcycles.” The order Trump signed over Canadian cars specifically excludes cars. It taxes furniture, clothing, cement, fishing rods, and hockey equipment. It’s difficult to find the connection
Specific Cultures separate business and personal life and issues. Diffuse cultures intertwin them. Canada and the U.S. are Specific Cultures, and while Trump is American, he does not seem to grasp the idea of separating different issues. Thus, he retaliates over a vehicle issue by taxing furniture and fishing rods and confuses provincial and national government functions, hinging a national trade agreement on a local alcohol issue.
Mark Carney understands how international relations and trade diplomacy operate. On 22 August, he offered to ask the provinces to restock American alcohol and to drop Canada’s remaining tariffs on American steel, aluminum and autos if Trump lowered his tariffs. Trump didn’t understand. Carney brought his negotiators home.
On 8 September, Canada will match Trump’s tariffs dollar for dollar. American steel, dairy, appliances, farm equipment, pulp and paper, electronics.
Carney is telling Canadians what it costs, which is more than Trump has told Americans. American importers pay Trump’s tariff and pass the higher cost on to Americans. Canadians will pay too. The difference is Trump has created an environment in which fewer nations want to trade with the U.S., and Carney has created an environment in which more nations want to trade with Canada:
Wildfire smoke. A Reagan commercial. A bottle of bourbon in Winnipeg. This is instability and incompetence.
Twenty agreements. Five continents. 1.5 billion customers. This is Canada Strong.
If you enjoyed this article, help support my work by becoming a paid subscriber or “Buy me a coffee.”
Get a solid understanding of Trompenaars’ cultural dimensions by purchasing the guide or subscribing to Cultural Perspective (free or paid) and receiving the guide for free.
this issue is a summary of everything we already know it's not news there's no analysis you are going to have to do better if you expect people to pay for a subscription to what you would like to output