Core Brief: What If California Seceded?
California’s secession sounds attractive, exciting, and a way out from under the Trump-Republian regime but it would be economically catastrophic.
The secession movement is gaining traction in California. And with Trump and Republicans essentially invading California with military troops, cutting billions in funding, and calling for the ouster of its democratically elected leader. It's already being treated as a hostile foreign country
Maybe independence and defense pacts with other countries are what it needs to survive, but probably not.
Secession is legal if 38 states and two-thirds of Congress agree. It’s also a political fantasy.
But what would happen if it did secede?
The News
California secession? It’s a possibility under Trump, supporters say
A leading Calexit advocate argues that Trump’s return to power makes secession more viable than ever. While most legal scholars disagree.
California will put secession back on the map
Reuters analysts predict that rising federal-state clashes, especially on immigration, climate, and spending, will put secession back in the public debate, even if it remains politically unlikely.
Los Angeles protests spark renewed calls for California independence, but is secession really possible?
Triggered by recent protests and state-federal conflict, the idea of California independence once again surfaces.
What Is Happening
In January 2024, California’s Secretary of State approved the circulation of a new initiative to place California secession, “Calexit 3.0,” on the 2026 ballot. Supporters have until mid-2025 to gather 546,651 valid signatures. The measure calls for a statewide vote to authorize negotiations with the US federal government for peaceful withdrawal.
This latest push follows the re-election of Donald Trump, his deployment of the national guard over the objection of California Governor Newsom, and the deployment of US Marines into California to intimidate Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass. This is on top of Trump taking billions in federal funding from California and federal-state clashes over immigration, climate policy, and the use of federal agents in California, and a host of other issues. Advocates argue the state’s values are incompatible with the Trump-Republican regime.
Even if passed, the ballot measure carries no legal force. Under Texas v. White (1869), no state can secede unilaterally. Only a constitutional amendment, approved by two-thirds of Congress and 38 states, could authorize a legal separation. Calexit remains a symbolic gesture, not an executable plan.
What Would Happen?
International Recognition
Along with a US constitutional amendment, California would need international recognition from other countries, including new treaties, trade agreements, and defence pacts. Even then, California would still need admission to the United Nations, the WTO, the IMF, and other international organizations. And California would need its own passport, visas, immigration control, and citizenship systems
As an independent country, would California use the dollar or print its own currency with an independent central bank? Either route would require recapitalising payment‑system infrastructure now run by the Fed.
The Economy
California’s $3.9 trillion gross state product is about 14 % of U.S. GDP and the world’s fourth‑largest economy. But a study of 124 secessions since 1940 found real GDP dropped by 24 % in the first decade, largely from trade disruption and transition costs. Creating an international frontier with the rest of the United States would raise trade frictions sharply and force supply‑chain re‑routing.
California sends about $83 billion more to Washington each year than it receives. But it would also lose over $600 billion in annual federal spending, like Social Security, Medicare, defense payrolls, and federal R&D. Net effect: a large initial budget hole unless new taxes or spending cuts offset lost transfers.
More than 30 % of California’s electricity and almost 90 % of its natural gas are imported from other US states. But California supplies over two‑thirds of U.S. lettuce, strawberries, and nuts, 80% of its wine, and is the leading dairy-producing state. Formal customs and regulatory checkpoints would raise costs unless a free‑trade‑and‑grid‑integration treaty were signed. \
Over all the US GDP would fall by ~14 %, and federal borrowing costs could rise because the Treasury would lose roughly one‑sixth of its tax base.
Defence
California hosts 44 major US military facilities, plus a large defense‑tech cluster. The US would have to realign its military strategy, particularly in the Pacific theater, where it would have to shift large ports to other states
California would have to fund its own armed forces at an annual outlay of roughly $80 – $160 billion, comparable to France or Germany.
Political
Secession would let Sacramento set its own agenda for climate mitigation, immigration, health care, transportation, and many other issues it is at odds with the Trump-Republican regime.
Losing California’s 52 House seats and 54 Electoral‑College votes would tilt the US federal system to the right; Democrats would lose their largest single congressional delegation.
The Cultural Perspective
Califronia
California’s progressive culture is future-focused, inclusive, and willing to take risks. It’s about innovation, new ideas, and bold experimentation. Success comes from creativity in business and government policy.
The state backs collective solutions to big problems. Flexibility is part of the culture—plans shift, ideas evolve, and progress is expected to take time.
Leaders are expected to listen. People are encouraged to speak up. Policies center on care, dignity, and inclusion, especially for those pushed to the margins. Healthcare for undocumented residents, mental health support, and multicultural education reflect that.
Freedom of thought is protected. Laws are grounded in science and ethics. Equality is non-negotiable; LGBTQ+ rights, immigrant protections, and racial justice are built into the system.
California draws strength from global diversity. It values community as much as the individual. And it believes innovation should serve people, not just profit.
Trump-Republican Regime
Trump-Republican culture is traditional, top-down, and loyal to its in-group. It emphasizes national identity, traditional values, and religious authority. Change is a threat, difference is dangerous, and the culture fights stay in the past.
Leaders are expected to be strong and citizens to be obedient. The rules don’t apply equally; who you know and how wealthy you are determine which laws you have to obey and what position you hold.
Group loyalty is more important than laws, morals, or ethics. The flag, the church, and the great leader come first.
Assertiveness permeates every aspect of life. Winning is everything. Control, not compromise, defines strength. Gender roles are clearly defined and strictly enforced, and deviation is moral depravity.
The world is uncertain, so the goal is to shut it out and hold the line.
Why It Matters
California’s peaceful exit would mark the most significant change to the US political map since the Civil War. It would rewire trade routes, alter military doctrine, and devastate federal finances.
Secession challenges the entire idea of what holds nations together: shared identity, mutual benefit, and long-term integration. And while the Trump-Republican regime is working to divide the nation, those ideas are still robust.
If California succeeds, it sets a precedent for all others to follow. The bigger danger is not secession, it’s the slow unraveling of the United States.
Join us for more perspectives on TikTok and YouTube
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser